Feeling like your spouse is unreliable can be deeply disappointing. Life is hard enough—raising kids, working, managing responsibilities—without feeling like you can’t depend on your partner. For many couples, unreliability creates frustration, resentment, and even questions like: “Can I stay in this marriage if my spouse doesn’t change?”
Here are some common reasons your partner may be unreliable—and practical steps you can take to create change before making big decisions.
1. Could ADHD Be a Factor?
One of the most overlooked reasons for unreliability in marriage is ADHD. Many couples don’t realize it’s a factor until years of frustration pile up. Research shows that untreated ADHD can lead to forgetfulness, unfinished tasks, impulsivity, and mismanaged time—all of which impact a partner’s sense of dependability.1
It took us a while to realize that ADHD was plaguing our own marriage. Suddenly, the patterns made sense—big dreams but unfinished projects, promises not followed through, and mounting disappointment.
👉 If this resonates, consider seeking an evaluation from a psychiatrist or neuropsychologist. Diagnosis and treatment (therapy, coaching, or medication) can dramatically improve reliability and restore hope.
2. The Impact of Shame and Criticism
Sometimes unreliability is less about diagnosis and more about relationship dynamics. If your home has become an environment of shame, nagging, or criticism, your spouse may shut down.
Why? Because many people—especially those who grew up in critical or shaming households—go into fight, flight, or freeze mode when confronted. In this case, “tuning out” isn’t laziness; it’s a defense mechanism.2
Instead of criticism, research from the Gottman Institute suggests focusing on:
-
Gentle start-ups (raising issues calmly, without blame)
-
Appreciation and praise (reinforcing what your partner does well)
-
Creating emotional safety so that follow-through becomes possible
3. Building a Safer, More Dependable Relationship
The cycle is clear:
-
You feel less on edge when your partner is reliable.
-
Your partner feels safer and more motivated when criticism is replaced with trust and respect.
This doesn’t mean tolerating irresponsibility forever. But it does mean experimenting with new dynamics before concluding your spouse “will never change.” Often, dependability improves dramatically when both partners work on creating emotional safety and addressing root causes.
Key Takeaways
-
ADHD is a common but overlooked factor in marital unreliability—seek assessment if symptoms fit.
-
Criticism and shame backfire—they make unreliability worse by triggering defense mechanisms.
-
Emotional safety improves follow-through—when partners feel less threatened, they often step up.
-
Rebuilding trust takes two—it starts with new communication patterns and sometimes professional support.
-
If unreliability continues despite changes, consider counseling or ADHD-focused coaching before deciding on next steps.
- Learning how to create safe interactions, a calm home where negativity is rare and shaming or criticizing comments are refrained from, will help create an environment where each of you can feel safe to show up and perform optimally.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. How do I deal with an unreliable spouse?
Start by identifying the root cause. Is it ADHD, poor time management, stress, or relationship dynamics like criticism and shame? Once you understand the “why,” you can respond with empathy instead of only frustration. Encourage professional evaluation if ADHD is suspected, and try shifting from criticism to calm communication.
2. Can a marriage survive if my spouse is unreliable?
Yes, but it depends on how both partners approach the issue. Research shows that marriages where partners work together to reduce negativity and increase emotional safety are more likely to improve reliability over time.[^1] If the unreliability is tied to untreated ADHD or other challenges, therapy and coaching can be transformative.
3. What if my spouse promises to change but never follows through?
This is one of the most common frustrations. If promises are consistently broken, it’s important to:
-
Set clear boundaries around responsibilities.
-
Agree on small, manageable steps instead of vague commitments.
-
Consider outside help (counseling, ADHD coaching, accountability structures).
If nothing changes despite consistent efforts, it may be time to evaluate the future of the relationship.
4. When should unreliability be a dealbreaker?
Unreliability becomes a dealbreaker when it consistently undermines your safety, security, or ability to function as a family. If your spouse’s actions (or lack thereof) put you or your children at risk, or if trust cannot be rebuilt despite repeated attempts, professional guidance is essential. Sometimes, separation is the healthiest option.
5. How can I encourage my spouse to be more dependable?
-
Replace criticism with appreciation where possible.
-
Use calm, specific requests instead of general complaints.
-
Reinforce follow-through with gratitude (“Thanks for paying that bill on time—it really helps me feel less stressed”).
-
Create structures that support reliability (shared calendars, task reminders, division of labor).
- When emotional safety increases, many spouses naturally step up.
Sources
Barkley, R. A. (2015). Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder: A Handbook for Diagnosis and Treatment. Guilford Press. ↩
Gottman, J. & Silver, N. (2015). The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work. Harmony Books. ↩
